Mexitaly Pizza
Salsa, chorizo, cheese and beans with sour cream, guacamole and pico de gallo.
Mexican × Italian · East York, PA
Two Kitchens,
Two Kitchens,
One Craving
Where Mexican fire meets Italian soul - chorizo pizza, cheesesteak stromboli, and burritos built like legends. East York's boldest fusion, delivered hot.
Order Online
The Mexitaly Mash-Up
Two Worlds,
Two Worlds,
One Plate
At Mexitaly we do the impossible on purpose - chorizo meets mozzarella, stromboli meets salsa, and every burrito gets built like a legend. Born in East York, PA, our kitchen blends bold Mexican spice with hearty Italian comfort so nothing here tastes like anywhere else. Huge portions, fresh guacamole, hand-rolled meatballs and a pizza sauce people swear by. Come hungry, leave loud.
Fusion, Done Bold
Crowd Legends
The Heavy Hitters
Cheesesteak Stromboli
Steak, onions and cheese rolled into golden, crispy dough.
Italian Stromboli
Pepperoni, ham, sausage, cheese and sauce with a light amount of mustard.
Chimichanga
Deep-fried pocket of dough with your choice of meat, beans and cheese. Served with rice, beans and guacamole.
Side of 3 Meatballs
Three hand-rolled meatballs in a rich tomato sauce with a hint of chipotle and fresh herbs.
California Steak Burrito
Steak, french fries, cheese, pico, guacamole and sour cream.
Word on the Street
4.6
587 ratings
This is the only MARGHERITA PIZZA that I want from this town. and Ill even go so far to say that Mexitaly is the only pizza I want around here, period. THE SAUCE is just to die for. That zest is unlike any other sauce and it just something you want to bathe in really. We live 15 mins from here so the one thing we understand is that it won't arrive super hot. That crust! Cruspy, airy, and chewy in all the right ways. Honestly it's not only great fresh at the restaurant, but it's also super easy to reheat on a preheated pizza stone at 500 degrees for a few mins (in an absolute pinch) to bring it back to life after its Door Dash trip to our house. I love that! Versatilty. Anything from Mexitaly is killer, but I swear by their MARGHERITA PIZZA. I literally order it any chance I get! Extra Basil please
Erin R
So good! Huge portions and very filling. The small TACORRITO is quite big. Thebeef enchiladas had perfect amount of heat... not too hot, just right!
Stacy S
Amazing. Best spaghetti I ever had. Plus large portion. It is very flavorful and delicious.
Joni K
Good to Know
Questions & Answers
What meals do you serve?
Mexitaly serves a unique fusion of Mexican and Italian cuisine perfect for lunch, dinner, and casual dining occasions. Our menu features crowd favorites like the Mexitaly Pizza topped with salsa, chorizo, cheese, beans, sour cream, guacamole, and pico de gallo. Italian-inspired options include the Cheesesteak Stromboli and Italian Stromboli loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage, and cheese. Craving Mexican? Try our crispy Chimichanga stuffed with your choice of meat, beans, and cheese, served with rice and guacamole. We also offer handcrafted sides like our signature meatballs with a chipotle-infused tomato sauce.
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, Mexitaly offers both delivery and pickup. Order conveniently online or by phone.
Where are you located?
Mexitaly is located at 2440 E Market St, East York, PA 17402.
What areas do you serve?
Mexitaly proudly serves East York, York, Springettsbury Township, Manchester, Red Lion, Dallastown, York Township, Hallam, Hellam, Strinestown, and surrounding communities in York County, PA.
Find Us in East York
Visit Us
When We're Cooking
- Monday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Tuesday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Wednesday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Thursday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Friday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Saturday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
- Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM